First Come, First Served is The OverUnder's 2009 five song EP. The band has made one music video for That Necktie Makes You Look Ridiculous.
- First Come, First Served (1:25)
- That Necktie Makes You Look Ridiculous (3:18)
- Crowd Surf (2:55)
- Somewhere Along the Way (3:10)
- Where the Stars Fall (3:30)